Battle of the Suits

(Corrected below.)

An interesting kerfuffle blew up in Chicago last week when the CEO of the Tribune Company, which owns WGN, sent a memo to the station’s news department containing 119 words and phrases that are no longer to be uttered by anchors and reporters on the air. WGN’s news director passed it on to longtime Chicago media reporter Robert Feder, who published it on his website. The list itself isn’t all that objectionable—it includes a lot of cliches and lazy newscaster jargon, although I’m not sure how a reporter will write around now-forbidden words like “officials,” “authorities,” “alleged,” and “undisclosed.” The broader issue is whether the CEO of the parent company should be making such a list in the first place, or sending it directly to the staff, bypassing the myriad managers between the CEO’s office and the news department.

The Tribune CEO is Randy Michaels, and his biography is not that of the typical corporate suit—he came up as a jock, became a group program director in the 80s, eventually put together a station group, then sold it to Clear Channel in 1999, becoming CEO there through 2002. (As such, he’s one of the architects of the massive consolidation that plagues the industry today.) He began overseeing the Tribune Company’s broadcasting and interactive operations and some of its newspapers in 2007. So he’s got a background in radio programming, but he’s also got a program director at WGN, Kevin Metheny, a guy with his own substantial resume and a track record of success. Had the list of banned words come down through channels, from Michaels to Metheny to the poor news director, Charlie Meyerson, it might never have made it to the public eye. But given the genesis of the list, it’s easy to understand why Meyerson gave it to Feder: When you’ve got nothing—as in power, authority, or your own cojones anymore—you’ve got nothing to lose.

(Digression: The Michaels/Metheny reign at WGN the last couple of years has coincided with the torching of the station’s substantial legacy as one of America’s great full-service AM stations in favor of becoming just another major-market talk station chasing male listeners with sports, right-leaning politics, and juvenile attitude. The Mrs., a longtime WGN listener, is pissed. But that’s a topic for another post.)

You can argue—and some people will—that CEOs, or high corporate suits in general, should take a direct interest in programming. It’s where the battles are won and lost and where the money is made. If the CEO has a programming background, that’s one thing. (Randy Michaels has reportedly spent a lot of time over the years coaching newscasters to talk like real people.) But all of us in radio have run across guys who spent their entire careers in sales, but who believed that as soon as they got into the general manager’s office, they became experts in programming. Or owners who believed that just because they had enough money to buy a station, they knew how to run one day-to-day.

When the new owner of one of my stations came to town for the first time, we were dismayed to find that he’d never sold advertising, he’d never been a programmer, had never even been on the air—the only job he’d ever had in radio was as a station owner. And so he spent most of his first day at our station redesigning the station logo. (I suppose we should have been grateful that he didn’t start rewriting liner cards or rearranging the music library.) He later hired a general manager who suggested that our station should pick up St. Louis Cardinals baseball broadcasts. Never mind that there were few Cardinals fans in the market—we were a music station that depended on in-office listening during the working day. Baseball would have destroyed that image, and he was eventually persuaded to give up the idea.

That is not to say that all GMs are empty suits. The last GM I worked for as a full-timer loved getting involved in the day-to-day stuff, but he knew what he was doing—most of the time. (We would clash occasionally, but when we did, it wasn’t necessarily a foregone conclusion that I’d lose the argument.) His willingness to roll up his sleeves and do everything alongside the rest of the staff made it a lot easier for me to manage my people. They couldn’t claim they were being asked to do things that the GM himself wasn’t willing to do.

In the end, it’s a battle as old as radio itself—the conflict between programmers, who are paid to know what sounds good on the radio, and executives, who are paid more to worry about a bigger picture that includes what sounds good on the radio. Each of us is inclined to protect our turf. Ideally, we agree how to share it.


3 responses

  1. I was reading an article the other day about WLS talk show host, Roe Conn, and his woes. Over the past year several unpopular management decisions were made and Roe lost increasingly more and more editorioral control over his own show including the re-firing of co-host Christina Filiaggi (she’d been fired on 2/29/08 was rehired and then refired) and the letting go of Bill Leff through a management refusal to extend his contract. Of the 2, Leff’s departure was more of a loss. Bill Leff is a former stand-up comic and he has quite a quirky off-beat sense of humor. I miss his humorous interjections to some of Roe’s comments. Roe on his own can be funny… but Leff had an ability to take something that might not otherwise be funny and make it humorous by adding to it or with his impeccable comedic timing. They tried to replace Filiaggi and Leff with former Channel 5 reporter, Amy Jacobsen but it was an awkard match and she was under-utilized (rumor has it that WLS TV’s Ron Magers who ocassionally sits in with Roe as a co-host does not/did not like Jacobsen which likely led to her departure from the show). I was happy to read that Jacobsen landed on her feet over at WIND with former country music DJ turned talk radio host, Big John Howell replacing Cisco Cotto (who went back to WLS and now has his own show in Mancow & Cassady’s old 9-11 am slot). I’ve heard rumors that Roe Conn will be getting a new co-host (they tried Cisco Cotto out as Roe’s co-host when he first returned to WLS but it was a poor fit. The two styles didn’t mesh well). I’m keeping my fingers crossed that Bill Leff will be returning and rejoining the show.

  2. Feder says that Sun-Times columnist Richard Roeper will be joining Roe Conn in April:

    WLS has its own problems. It’s owned by Citadel, one of the giant consolidated chains that’s having trouble keeping its head above water. Conn had to take a pay cut (he’s no longer one of the few Chicago radio stars making over a million per) in exchange for a longer deal, but at least the station was willing to keep him.

  3. Amy Jacobson (and her bikini body) need to be on tv, not radio.

    I think Ron Magers’s problem with her was her bikini-style of gathering facts. Just a hunch.

    Ron Magers used to sit in w/ Roe and told some great “back in my day” type stories. Maybe he still does. I can’t keep track of the coming and goings of the Big 89.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: